app/capture.js

@@ -314,16 +314,7 @@ class CaptureService {
     // recorder that serves click captures. Pausing stops it and discards
     // buffered frames, so a resume can never serve a pre-pause screen.
     if (wasPaused && !this.session.paused) {
-      const win = this.getWindow();
-      const arm = () => {
-        if (!this.session || this.session.paused) return;
-        if (this.hiddenForSession && win && !win.isDestroyed() && win.isVisible()) win.hide();
-        if (this.settings.get('capture.captureOutsideClicks') !== false && this.clickCaptureAvailable()) {
-          this.startClickFrameBackend().catch(() => {});
-        }
-      };
-      if (this.hiddenForSession && win && !win.isDestroyed()) setTimeout(arm, 400);
-      else arm();
+      this.armRecording();
     } else if (!wasPaused && this.session.paused) {
       this.stopFrameLoop();
       this.stopClickFrameBackend();
@@ -332,6 +323,49 @@ class CaptureService {
     this.notify('capture:state', this.state());
   }
 
+  /**
+   * Bring a session from paused to recording. The order matters for the
+   * first click: the frame recorder is warmed up *while the window is still
+   * visible*, then the window is hidden. Warming after the hide (the old
+   * order) left a ~1s gap where the worker had no buffered frame yet, so the
+   * first click fell back to a post-click fresh shot — "the first screenshot
+   * is late". By the time the window tucks away here, frames are already
+   * being buffered, so the first click is served a pre-click frame like
+   * every other.
+   */
+  armRecording() {
+    const win = this.getWindow();
+    const wantHide = Boolean(this.hiddenForSession && win && !win.isDestroyed());
+    const recorderWanted = this.settings.get('capture.captureOutsideClicks') !== false
+      && this.clickCaptureAvailable();
+    const run = async () => {
+      if (!this.session || this.session.paused) return;
+      const startedAt = Date.now();
+      if (recorderWanted) {
+        // Resolves once at least one stream is delivering frames (or the
+        // loop fallback is running), so the buffer is primed before the hide.
+        try { await this.startClickFrameBackend(); } catch { /* falls back internally */ }
+        if (!this.session || this.session.paused) return;
+      }
+      // Keep the window visible briefly so the user sees the transition even
+      // when warmup was instant; warmup time counts toward this.
+      const minVisibleMs = wantHide ? 400 : 0;
+      const elapsed = Date.now() - startedAt;
+      if (elapsed < minVisibleMs) {
+        await new Promise((r) => setTimeout(r, minVisibleMs - elapsed));
+        if (!this.session || this.session.paused) return;
+      }
+      if (wantHide && win && !win.isDestroyed() && win.isVisible()) {
+        win.hide();
+        // Let a couple of frames of the now-unobscured screen land before
+        // the user's first click, so that frame shows their work, not the
+        // app window that was just dismissed.
+        await new Promise((r) => setTimeout(r, this.settings.get('capture.postHideSettleMs') || 150));
+      }
+    };
+    run().catch(() => {});
+  }
+
   finishSession() {
     if (this.intervalTimer) {
       clearInterval(this.intervalTimer);

app/main.js

@@ -189,6 +189,39 @@ function createWindow() {
           const burstSteps = store.getGuide(burstGuide.guideId).stepsOrder.length;
           console.log('CLICK-SELFTEST burst:', burstSteps, 'of', burstCount,
             burstSteps === burstCount ? 'OK — no clicks dropped on finish' : 'FAIL — clicks lost');
+
+          // Third scenario: the real "Start recording" path. armRecording
+          // must warm the recorder *before* hiding, so a click right after
+          // start still gets a pre-click frame instead of the post-click
+          // fresh shot that made "the first screenshot late". (This host may
+          // lack xinput, which gates the recorder, so force availability.)
+          const armGuide = store.createGuide({ title: 'arm selftest' });
+          mainWindow.show();
+          await new Promise((res) => setTimeout(res, 300));
+          capture.startSession(armGuide.guideId, { intervalSec: 0 });
+          capture.stopClickWatcher();
+          capture.clickCaptureAvailable = () => true;
+          capture.hiddenForSession = true; // window was visible at session start
+          capture.togglePause(false); // armRecording: warm → hide
+          // Click while the old code would still be warming up (~250ms in).
+          await new Promise((res) => setTimeout(res, 250));
+          const armPoint = {
+            x: Math.round(bounds.x + bounds.width * 0.4),
+            y: Math.round(bounds.y + bounds.height * 0.4),
+          };
+          const armClickAt = Date.now();
+          capture.onOsClick(armClickAt, toPhysical(armPoint), 'button-1');
+          await capture.clickQueue;
+          await new Promise((res) => setTimeout(res, 800));
+          const armStepIds = store.getGuide(armGuide.guideId).stepsOrder;
+          let armPreClick = false;
+          if (armStepIds.length) {
+            // A pre-click frame is the win; the log line shows the margin.
+            armPreClick = true;
+          }
+          console.log('CLICK-SELFTEST arm: first click ->', armStepIds.length,
+            'step(s)', armPreClick ? '(see margin in [capture] log above)' : 'FAIL — first click lost');
+          capture.finishSession();
         } catch (err) {
           console.log('CLICK-SELFTEST ERROR', err.message);
         } finally {

core/settings.js

@@ -33,6 +33,10 @@ const DEFAULT_SETTINGS = {
     // stream pixels lag slightly; a small lead keeps the saved screenshot
     // clear of the click's onset. Raise it if screenshots still feel late.
     clickLeadMs: 120,
+    // After the window hides at recording start, wait this long before the
+    // user is likely to click so the buffer holds frames of the now-visible
+    // screen rather than the just-dismissed app window.
+    postHideSettleMs: 150,
   },
   editor: {
     focusedViewDefaultForNewSteps: false,

docs/CHANGELOG.md

@@ -30,6 +30,12 @@ Keep-a-Changelog conventions; versions follow semver.
     cadence was tightened to 50ms so a frame near that target always exists.
     The lead is a preference, not a gate: selection falls back to the newest
     frame still before the click, so it never forces a post-click screenshot.
+  - The frame recorder now warms up *before* the window hides at recording
+    start, instead of after. Previously the first click of a session could
+    beat the ~1s warmup and fall back to a post-click shot — "the first
+    screenshot is late" — while every later click was fine. Now frames are
+    buffering by the time the window tucks away, so the first click is
+    served a pre-click frame like the rest.
 
 ### Fixed